Wednesday, September 08, 2010

Breakfast On The Go

Most Americans skip breakfast.  Some estimates put the number as high as 75%, and this includes not having a snack or beverage to "break the fast".  That first bite or drink of the day presents a gold mine of opportunities for savvy restaurant operators and food processors. 


For on-the-go consumers, sit-down breakfasts are a time constrained luxury.  Take-out options have been capitalized on by QSR chains and increasingly Midscale chains.  Real success, however, demands a leap from packaging and ordering convenience to dining convenience whether at one's desk, the company cafeteria or on the car dashboard.  To sell a breakfast that is both convenient to buy and to eat requires consumer awareness that the breakfast menu item is available.  The next step is creating the perception that ordering is quick and easy. 

 

Portability 

Survey research conducted with midscale chains reveals that 100% of breakfast items are available on a take out basis.  In other words, if it can be prepared, then it can be packaged and sold. We suspect that the vast majority of  midscale breakfast volume is dine-in and that patrons do not regard midscale chains as serious and efficient as QSR in developing the breakfast-to-go franchise. 

 

Plated entrees such as skillet breakfasts, egg entrees, breakfast cakes are perfect for dine-in situations.   Breakfast patrons, in practice, seem to favor Portable-Hand Held foods that may be eaten with one hand on the wheel or the keyboard or phone.  Migrating up the scale from Plated to Hand Held is an opportunity.  In the event leading meat, cereal and bakery suppliers do not come up with more portable breakfast options, breakthrough ideas may come from non-traditional foods or non-breakfast menu parts.  Approximately 50% of all breakfast food and beverage menu items in 2004 can be considered portable, up from 43% in 1998, indicating how important portability has become.  (Source MenuMine database)
 
 

Best --- Portable-Handheld: Coffee, Tea, Hot Chocolate, Juice, Milk, Breakfast Sandwiches, French Toast Sticks, Fresh Whole Fruits,  Baked Sweet Goods, Bagels and Biscuits, Hash Brown Patties/Tots, Burritos, Quesadillas, Wraps, Yogurt in a Tube 

Better --- Portable-Utensil Bound: Cereal Bowls to go, Yogurt in a Cup, Fruit in a Cup

Good --- Portable-Plated: Egg Entrees,  Pancakes, Waffles, French Toast, Skillet Entrees, Meat Sides, Hash Brown Sides

 

What Chains Are Menuing:

Here's what some chains are doing to meet on-the-go demand: 

Taco Cabana---BBQ Breakfast Burrito

IHOP---Country Griddle Cakes

Del Taco---Bacon & Egg Quesadilla

La Madeleine---Low Fat Organic Granola

McDonalds---Sausage McGriddles

Bob Evans---Breakfast Fruit Cup

Farmer Boys---Breakfast Burrito

Carl's Jr.---Breakfast Quesadilla

Village Inn---Ham & Swiss on a Croissant

Hof's Hut---Fajita Steak Omelet

Smokey Bones---Hot Cinnamon Donuts

Circle K---Apple Fritters

Wall Street Deli---Breakfast Wrap w/ Egg

LePeep---Granola Blues w/Sausage

 

 

QSR Chain Concepts Offering Breakfast

QSR chains that are most likely to serve breakfast are C-Stores and Coffee/Snack chains, all of which (100%) serve hot beverages such as coffee/tea and sweet baked goods.  Sandwich chains, on the other hand, have a 52% chance of serving hot beverages and a very low (25%) chance of serving a baked good, suggesting room to grow.  Burger, pizza and chicken chains have moderate incidence (20% to 60% incidence) of hot beverage service and even lower incidence of baked goods (20% to 25%).  Starbucks, Dunkin’ Donuts and others have understood and exploited this understanding of a “coffee and baked good” breakfast.  Indeed, 24% of portable food and beverage items on chain menus in 2004 are specialty coffees, up from 12% of the total in 1998.  

 

 QSR Chain Concept

 Baked Good (% serving)

 Hot Beverage (% serving)

 C-Store Chains  100%  100%
 Coffee/Snack Chains  100%  100%
 Sandwich Chains  25%  52%
 Burger Chains  21%  65%
 Chicken Chains  18%  51%
 Pizza Chains  0%  21%
 Others (seafood, asian, mexican)  0%  42%

 

 

Breakfast Sandwiches

Perhaps the biggest influence on portable breakfast is the breakfast sandwich.  Ever since McDonald’s showed the way with the Egg McMuffin, breakfast sandwiches have been selling better than hot cakes.  Breakfast sandwiches now account for 32% of menued portable breakfast foods (and perhaps 40% of volume) in 2004, up from 26% in 1998.  Not every QSR chain on every corner, however, serves breakfast.  C-Stores, Sandwich Chains and Burger Chains are the most likely QSR segments to serve breakfast sandwiches.  Pizza and Mexican segments seem to be holding back. 

 

 

Share of  Breakfast Sandwiches Menued    

A greater variety of breakfast sandwiches are now being offered by a more diverse group of QSR chains. Back in 1998, burger chains accounted for 42% of breakfast sandwiches on the menu; today it's 35%.  The reason is Sandwich/Bakery chains, C-Stores and Coffee/Snack chains have all increased their number of Breakfast Sandwiches.  In fact, only Chicken QSRs have decreased their number:  

 

 

Share of Breakfast Sandwiches Menued, by QSR Segment

 QSR Chain Concept

 2004

 1998

 Burger Chains
 35%  42%
 Sandwich/Bakery Chains
 33%  30%
 C-Store Chains  11%  3%
 Mexican QSR Chains  7%  7%
 Chicken QSR Chains  7%  14%
 Coffee/Snack Chains
 7%  4%
 Total:  100%  10

 

 

 

Cakes vs. Eggs

Pancakes, Waffles, French Toast, Crepes and other breakfast cake entrees are a mainstay of menus.  Cakes make up 45% of all hot entrees compared to 55% for egg entrees.  Going back to similar MenuMine records from 1996, indicates cakes are up 1% and eggs down 1%, but there is no way to relate this to a volume estimate. 

 

Leading Specialty Coffees For Breakfast (basis: share of menu)

Cafe Mocha (24%), Cappuccino (20%), Espresso (18%), Cafe Latte (18%), Other (20%)---Total: 100%

 

Leading Sauces at Breakfast  (basis: share of menu)

Country Gravy (33%), Hollandaise Sauce (16%), Salsa (12%), Sausage Gravy (11%), Sour Cream (7%), Ranchera Sauce (6%), Cheese Sauce (6%)---Total: 100% 

 

Bottom line

Breakfast in foodservice has considerable potential but needs operational growth.  Suggestions include more midscale drive thru’s and more QSR Chains serving breakfast.  On the product side, suggestions include more sandwiches, whether enrobed, wrapped, sliced or deep fried.  After the success of breakfast burritos, menu developers should be emboldened.  AM Pizza sounds like a tasty idea, with a lot of cheese, a little or none at all.  Yogurt in a tube was also a great idea and opens up the prospect of new cereal delivery products, breakfast smoothies/shakes, even breakfast soup.  

If the foodservice industry can forge a one percent gain in the number of adults eating breakfast, that translates into 2.1 million more meals per day.  We say that is worth going after. 

 

Move
-

Other MenuMine Trend Articles

Top Headline

Sandwiches Top the New Item list for 2010

Sandwiches Top the New Item list for 2010

Sandwiches are way out ahead,  accounting for a 15% share of almost 3700 new items added to chain menus in the first 8 months of 2010.   Read More...

Versatility of Mushrooms

Versatility of Mushrooms

The average price of menu items using mushrooms in 2009 is $11.51, up from $10.75 in 2007.  

Read More...

Prepared Entree Trends in 2009

Prepared Entree Trends in 2009

There is a considerable difference in preparation and average prices between Center of Plate Entrees and Prepared Entrees. COP entrees include a whole cut protein, whether a chicken breast or tender,...

Read More...

Newsletter Signup



Sample Newsletter

To view an unbranded sample PDF of our custom newsletters writing service, click the image below.

NewsletterSampleThumb.jpg

MenuMine Trend

  • Emerging Sauces MenuMine has identified more than 2000 unique sauces and toppings in addition to another few thousand unique dressings, marinades, glazes, condiments, spreads, seasonings and dips. Needless to say, tomorrow's flavor heroes are now beginning to creep up from the bottom of usage tables, where they may have ascended from 0.3% to 0.9% to 1.2% and now...
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8

Login Form